Here is a photo of Peter's tombstone sent to me by Deborah Thomas. It's in Evergreen Cemetery in Tallman, NY.
From Ronny Bodine:
Peter Bodine never married and lived his entire life with his parents.
From Airmont Lutheran Church Burials Records, Rockland County:
Beckner Bodine died 17 Oct 1912 in Middletown, NY aged 43 years. Buried 19 Oct 1912.
Burials in Evergreen Cemetery, Ramapo, Rockland County.
(Find A Grave Memorial # 7414806)
Peter Beckner son of Rev. J. V. & M. H. Bodine 1869 - 1912