Notes for: Esther A. Budine

From the census info below, it would not seem that Esther is a daughter of Moses Budine since she comes after Mary CLOSE - whoever that is. I would think Esther would be a daughter of Mary Close. We are not sure so we will leave her as a daughter of Moses and Catherine Budine for now.

1850 (14 Nov) Andes, Delaware Co.: Moses BUDINE 44 farmer, Catharin 42, Stephen 21 laborer, Cynthia 19, Wm. 18 laborer, Elizabeth 17, Marcus 16, Jane 14, Martin 13, John 12, Asa 11, Sarah 9, Mary CLOSE 24, Esther A. BUDINE 2. All born in NY.

From: Ronny Bodine
Sent: Sunday, January 08, 2017
Subject: Re: A Budine question

Hey Dave,

No idea who Mary Close is. Not a daughter as there is already a Mary Jane in the family. All indications are is that Esther was a child of Moses and his wife and died before 1855. Catherine was 40 when Esther was born.

Ronny