Notes for: Charles Terbell Bodine
In the marriages at the DRC in Montgomery, New York, there is a Charles T. Bodine who married a Crissie Terwilliger on September 10, 1840. I would bet it was this Charles. They are both listed as being from Walden. Ralph Weller also suspects that Crissie Terwilliger is this Charles' wife. Crissie is probably the Ann Lucretia Bodine buried in the Montgomery DRC Cemetery. She died July 28, 1841 at age 21-11-19 (b. 8/9/1819). She is listed as the wife of Charles T. Bodine. She was probably the daughter of Nathaniel Terwilliger and Sarah Constable. They had a daughter baptized at the Shawangunk DRC who was born on August 28, 1818 (I think this is what my source said).
This Charles married Susan Cranse Bodine on March 2, 1848 in Montgomery, NY. I did have the date and place as 1849 in Walden, but there was no source for that info. The source for the 1848 date is Vital Records Orange County 1847-1849: Marriages
- 3/2/1848 Charles T. Bodine of Montgomery age 30 to Susan C. Bodine of Montgomery age 24 @ Montgomery.
From Ronny Bodine (Jan. 18, 2021):
1st marriage--1840--ANN LUCRETIA (CRISSIE) TERWILLIGER.
From Brick Reformed Church of Montgomery, Orange County, Marriages:
10 Sept 1840 Charles T. Bodine of Walden and Crissie Terwilliger of Walden. Witnesses were David Crist & Samuel Sears.
Crissie Terwilliger and Ann Lucretia appear to be the same individual despite the conflict in her birth date. It may be that she was born 1 Aug 1818 and baptized 28 Aug 1818, leaving her age at death in error by one year.
From Shawangunk Dutch Reformed Church, Ulster County, Baptisms:
Ann Lucretia Terwilliger, bapt. 28 Aug 1818. Parents-Nathaniel I. Terwilliger & Sarah Cunstable.
Burials in the Brick Reformed Church Cemetery, Montgomery, Orange County.
From inscriptions copied August 1924. Two entries for the same burial.
p. 26. Ann Lucretia wife of Charles Bodine Died 28 July 1841 21 y 11 m 19 d [= birth date of 1 Aug 1819.]
p. 29. Ann Lucretia wife of Charles T. Bodine Died 2 July 1841 21y 11m 19d [=birth date of 13 July 1819]
2nd marriage--1848--SUSAN CRANSE BODINE
From Orange County Marriages 1847-1849: 2 March 1848 at Montgomery, Charles T. Bodine, 30 and Susan C. Bodine, 24, both of Montgomery.
From Brick Reformed Church of Montgomery, Orange County, Baptisms:
Susan Cranse, born 3 March 1825 to Lewis J. Bodine & Mary Blake
1850 (28 Sept) Montgomery, Orange Co., NY: Charles T. BODINE 29 NY Laborer, Susan 25 NY, Alanson (male) 8 NY, Sarah 3/12 NY.
1855 (9 June) Montgomery, Orange Co., NY: Charles T. BODINE 36, Susan C. 29 wife, Alanson T. 13 child, Sarah 5 child. All persons born in Orange Co.
1860 (8 Aug) Montgomery, Orange Co., NY: Mary BODINE 75 NY, Susan 34 NY, Charles T. 48 NY Farm Laborer, Sarah 10 NY.
1865 (4 July) Montgomery, Orange Co., NY: Charles T. BODINE 47 laborer, Susan C. 40 wife, Sarah 14 child, Mary 80 mother. All persons born in Orange Co.
1875 (4 June) Montgomery, Orange Co., NY: Charles T. BODINE 55 laborer, Susan 48 wife, Sarah M. 24 dau. All persons born in Orange Co.
1880 (15 June) Montgomery, Orange Co., NY: Charles T. BODINE 62 NY Laborer, Susan 53 NY wife, William TERWILLIGER 27 NY Carpenter, Sarah M. TERWILLIGER 29 NY wife, Job BODINE 60 NY single Boarder Laborer Inflamation of the bowels.
From New York Death Records:
Charles T. Bodine died 2 May 1897 in Walden, Orange County.
Susan C. Bodine died 13 May 1904 in Walden, Orange County.
1900 (2 June) Walden, Montgomery, Orange Co., NY: William B. TERWILLIGER March 1848 NY Carpenter married 25 years, Sarah M. Feb 1851 NY wife married 25 years 0 children, Susan C. BODINE March 1825 NY widowed 1 child born/1 living.
Burials in Wallkill Valley Cemetery, Walden, Orange County, New York.
(Find A Grave Memorial # 84590348 & 84590578)
William B. Terwilliger 1852-1922 Susan M. Bodine His Wife 1850-1906 Susan C. Bodine 1825-1904