His son Isaac N. Bodine, listed in the 1880 Census of Nelson Co., KY, says his father was born in Virginia and his mother in Kentucky. It looks like some of his other siblings may have been born in Kentucky, but I am still looking into this.
This stone was erected in the 1980's or 1990's in the graveyard at Beech Fork United Methodist Church in Bloomfield, Kentucky by (I guess) some of the descendants of Cornelius Bodine. The dates for Gilly are "b. 1793, d. 1869." The inscription says, "They owned the land around this cemetery. Many descendants buried here." The church appears in the picture below. The cemetery is right next to the church.
Cornelius and Gillwater were married by J. Ferguson.
The following was extracted from the "Kentucky Genealogist," v. 5, 1963, pages. 123-129. It was then arranged by family (by Rudie Slaughter?). Information in parentheses was added by the people who submitted the article to the "Kentucky Genealogist" in order to make some things clearer.
Cornelius Bodine (b. 1783) Family
Cornelius Bodine son of Isaac (A.) and Elizabeth (P.) was born ------1783.
1- Mary P. Bodine daughter of Cornelius and Gilly was born October 3, 1811 ("Gilly" is Gillwater Robertson)
2- Elizabeth Bodine daughter of Cornelius and Gilly was born December 22, 1813.
3- Isaac Bodine son of Cornelius and Gilly was born July 15, 1815.
4- Buford Cornelius Bodine son of Cornelius and Gilly was born ---1821. Buford C. Bodine son of Cornelius and Gilly died November 3, 1823.
Will of Cornelius Bodine, son of Isaac A. Nelson Co. KY Will Book (?) p. 522 (extracted).
Will of Cornelius Bodine "weak in body" asks that just debts be paid first by selling such of the stock and loose property as will discharge them, and then gives to beloved wife Gilly Bodine all the balance of the estate, both real and personal, during widowhood, allowing her full liberty to give to any of the children after they come of age or marry such part as she can conveniently spare and if she thinks they are in need of it, but not more than their proportional share to each. If she should marry, she is to have one-third of the estate during her life, and at her death, the same to be equally divided among all the children. The other two-thirds to be equally divided among the children when she should marry. If any of the slaves should not be dutiful, she can hire them out to the best advantage. Appoints brother Asher Bodine and Andrew Briggs as executors. April 18, 1823. William M. Foster and William Paddock witnesses. Probated May 18, 1823. Asher Bodine qualified as executor and entered into bond of $15,000 with Joseph Ray, William M. Foster, and Redmon Grigsby as his sureties.
From Ronny Bodine:
From the Bible of Isaac A. Bodine:
Mary P. Bodine daughter of Cornelius and Gilly was born October 3, 1811
Elizabeth Bodine daughter of Cornelius and Gilly was born December 22, 1813
Isaac Bodine son of Cornelius and Gilly was born July 15, 1815
Buford Cornelius Bodine son of Cornelius and Gilly was born 1821
From Nelson County, Kentucky Marriage Records:
Cornelius Bodine and Gilly Robertson were married 7 Oct 1810.
From Kentucky Federal Census Records:
1850 (5 Sept) Nelson Co.: Gilly BODINE 57 KY, John R. 31 KY Farmer.
1860 (15 Aug) Nelson Co.: Gilly BODINE 68 KY, Mary 18 KY, Mary WEBB 24 KY, Cornelius THOMAS 28 KY.
Burials in Beech Fork United Methodist Church, Bloomfield, Nelson County.
(Joint grave marker placed in the 1980s or 1990s.)
In memory of Cornelius Bodine 1783-1823 Gilly Robertson Bodine 1793-1869
"They owned the land around this cemetery. Many descendants buried here."
Gillwater was the daughter of John Robertson and Mary Parker.
The will of Cornelius Bodine was written 18 April 1823 and therein named his wife Gilly Bodine and makes reference to children, but does not name them. Executors are his brother Asher Bodine and Andrew Briggs. The will was proved 19 May 1823. (Nelson County Wills, vol. D [1817-1823], p. 522.)