Notes for: Catherine Bodine
I did have James Sutphin as her husband, but according to the "Hunterdon County Democrat," December 30, 1846 (v. 9, no. 19, p. 434), Catherine Bodine, daughter of John Bodine, Esq., married James Sutphin on December 22, 1846. That was well before this Catherine was born. James, John, and Catherine were all from Raritan.
There is no Catherine listed in the household of John and Jane Bodine in the 1880 Census of 1st Ward, District 2, Trenton, Mercer Co., NJ.