P. H. gave her birth date as December 19, 1831. He also sent me a picture of their gravestone. For some reason, the dates are blotted out for Lewis. The name on the gravestone is actually Lewis, but P. H. says it should be Louis.
From Ronny Bodine:
1855 Montgomery, Orange Co., NY: Erastus HATCH 48, Lewis M. HATCH 24 son wagon maker, Sarah 23 dau-in-law & others. Lewis & Sarah born in Orange County.
1860 Montgomery, Orange Co., NY: Lewis M. HATCH 30 NY carpenter, Sarah 27 NY, William 5 NY, Levina 2 NY.
1870 Montgomery, Orange Co., NY: Lewis M. HATCH 40 NY works in knife fact., Sarah 38 NY, Willie 14 NY, Levinia 12 NY, George 5 NY.
1875 Montgomery, Orange Co., NY: Lewis M. HATCH 45 cutter, Sarah 43 wife, Willie 19 son, Lavinia 16 dau. All born in Orange County.
1880 Montgomery, Orange Co., NY: Lewis HATCH 50 cutter, Sarah 49 NY wife, William A. 24 NY son, Lavina 22 NY dau, George 16 NY son, Perry 10 NY son.
From New York Death Records:
Lewis M. Hatch died 3 April 1887 in Walden, Orange County.
Sarah E. Hatch died 19 April 1895 in Walden, Orange County.
Burials in Wallkill Valley Cemetery, Walden, Orange County, New York
Lewis M. Hatch 1830-1887 Sarah E. Bodine 1831-1895 George B. Hatch 1864-1887