Notes for: Sarah (Sally) Milliken Bodine

Sarah M. Bodine was still living with her mother at the time of the 1850 Census of Montgomery, Orange Co., NY.

From: sirbold at juno.com
Sent: Monday, July 12, 2004
Subject: Lewis Bodine of Montgomery NY


ello Dave,


am enjoying all of your Bodine in America family info on freepages.genealogy.

I would like to contribute. I am a gr gr gr grand-son of Lewis I. Bodine via his 2nd wife Mary Blake and their daughter Sally 'Sarah' Ann Bodine. I have Sarah's Bible given to her by Mary Blake. In the records section is the Lewis I Bodine marriage to Mary Blake on April 10, 1810.

I would like to send you a scanned .jpg of it. It is also on file at the Orange co, NY Gen. soc.library in Goshen.


would like to continue a dialogue with you about the Bodine family. I agree with about the william Bodine and son Jacob (father of my Lewis I. ) as supposed status.


evin Elliott

From: jeff2178 [jeff217811 at gmail.com]
Sent: Monday, June 13, 2022
Subject: Possible Relation and a Question

Good Morning,
My name is Jeffrey Bonicioli and after doing some research on my family, it seems that I am related to the Bodines. If I have it correctly, Emil Capone is my grandfather, while his mother is Luetta S Elliot is the daughter of Katherine Kellogg Neafie, who is the daughter of Sarah (Sally) Milliken Bodine which makes her my 3rd great grandmother.
I was redoing my ancestry family tree in the past month due to me wondering if I had any American Revolution soldiers on my side and after doing a lot of detective and guessing work, I got to the name of John (I think Garrett) Neafie. I am having trouble with him as there are two possible people he could be. One which I think is correct died in Orange County, New York in the year 1816. The other is buried here in New Jersey. I was wondering if you have any information if I am on the correct track on any of this. Here is the link for John in New Jersey which is in question

Anything you can provide is deeply appreciated
Thank you for taking time out to read this and helping.


From Ronny Bodine:

From Christian Intelligencer of the Reformed Dutch Church (New York City) of 16 Oct 1851.
On Wednesday, the 15th inst.,in the Spring Street Church, by the Rev. Dr. Campbell, Augustus Neafie to Sarah M. Bodine, all of Walden, Orange County. [Note: The church is located in Manhattan, New York County.]

From New York Federal Census Records:
1870 (1 July) Montgomery, Orange Co.: Ary NEAFIE 44 NY Farmer, Sarah M. 42 NY, Marietta 16 NY, Charles 12 NY, Edward 10 NY, George H. 7 NY, Kate N. 5 NY, Mary A. BODINE 33 NY.

From New Jersey Federal Census Records:
1910 (23 April) Bayonne, Hudson Co.: Egbert SEYMOUR 59 NY married1-37 years Merchant, Marietta 57 NY wife married1-37 years, Sarah N. NEAFIE 87 NY widowed 7 children born/3 living mother-in-law.